Skip to content
Login

The Fast Food Political Party

Posted by Grahame Broadbelt at 4:59pm on Wednesday, 22nd March 2006

Social and political activism is alive and well, but has nothing to do with political parties or their machinery. The answer, for some, is for political parties to figure out how the single issue campaigns and hugely successful voluntary sector organisations are getting it so right, and then to copy that approach. This feels hugely satisfying as a tactic and leads to a long list on a flipchart of stuff that political parties could do.


But it seems to me that political parties must be more than containers for a collection of modern day consumers seeking the instant satisfaction of getting their issue attended to. As political parties widen their attempts to be that container (by trying to appeal to every interest, every sliver of opinion, every issue), they in turn look fragmented, disconnected and rootless. And all the time their constituencies are shrinking.

What we are seeing is a fragmentation of our social and political concerns into bite-sized chunks appropriate to our poor attention spans and intellectual diet. Such a fragmentation invades our discourse, pollutes our narrative and ends up with lots of really clever people sitting round a table not managing to talk about what political parties are actually for. Call me na�ve, but I thought political parties were about the development and enactment of political ideology (remember that; we used to talk about it a lot in the days before fizzy drinks and fast food).

The reason why people joined political parties (and voted for them) was because parties believed in something: a vision, a worldview, a set of political principles. And when in government we trust them to apply their ideology to the problems we collectively face. We hold them to account on their integrity, not the detail of the action which we were happy to delegate to their judgement. This is why the issue of trust is so central to the health of our political process. Single issue campaigns may have valuable lessons for political parties, but for me at least, they don�t offer a model that can simply be replicated as we try to reverse parties� declining role in our democracy.

Comments

1
I think you have a point here about the slow death of political ideology and the appearance of the consumer-voter to replace the citizen. Even though I find this sad, I think it could still be sustainable and democratic if voters really believed in the ability of governments and local councils to act upon their manifesto commitments - and not to be at the mercy of much larger forces. This is not helped by the drift, or the sprint, towards centralism in recent years. Local councils have largely been divested of any powers by central government and are mainly commissioners and providers of services dictated and financed by Whitehall. Regional government is a complete shambles, has no pretence to be democratic and will largely be used to monitor the performance of local government. Central govt is trying to decide the level and nature of local services that would have been unthinkable 20 years ago. Result - some levels of govt have responsibility without authority, others have authority without responsibility and some have authority without having a clue what is needed. When the met county councils and the GLC were elected in 1981 many introduced supplementary rates to support investment in public transport. It was highly unpopular in some quarters, very popular in others - but there was a vigorous debate and a very healthy turnout. Why? Not because people were particularly idelogical (although we were still in the Cold War and hadn't reached the 'death of politics' signified by the fall of the Berlin Wall), but because everyone knew their vote could make a significant difference to the level of rates and the quality of public services they might get. They now know that their vote will make very little difference to either - so why bother?
Posted by Colin Noble  at 7:12pm on Thursday, 23rd March 2006

LOGIN to add comments