Fyi910x200

The new politics of personal information

We live in an information age - and increasingly, a personal information age. In many ways we are reaping the rewards, from the potential for more efficient government, better customer service, and more ways for us to influence and manipulate what people think of us.

But we have yet to understand the consequences of our reliance on personal data. That means that people do not have enough of a say about how their personal information is used. As a result, we are losing control over what people and organisations think about us.

We need policy, technology, legal frameworks and practices that put people at the centre of the flows of their personal information.

What we're doing
We launched the FYI: the new politics of personal information pamphlet on 7th December 2007. We were delighted to be joined by the Information Commissioner Richard Thomas, BBC technology critic Bill Thompson, and comedian and columnist Natalie Haynes.

You can download a pdf copy of the pamphlet FYI: the new politics of personal information for free here. You can watch a video about the research on the DemosTV YouTube channel here.

Next steps: People's Inquiry into Identity Technologies
The next phase of our research will focus on developing the public voice in the personal information debate. We want to run a People's Inquiry into identity technologies - an experiment in exploring public attitudes to the political, technological and legal implications of identity technologies.

You can download our project proposal for FYI: A People's Inquiry into Identity Technologies, here. We will follow the research with a conference at Wilton Park next June.

Do get in touch if you would like to talk to us about the FYI research, are interested in collaborating or would like to know more about our future work in this area.

For more about People's Inquiry is, see our Nanodialogues pamphlet.


Recommendations from FYI: the new politics of personal information

People themselves must be put at the centre of information flows. Our findings suggested a number of measures that government, the private sector and individuals could follow to improve the relationship between people, personal information and the institutions that use that information.

For individuals, we recommend:

The first step is for individuals to take measures to protect their personal information. Second,they must recognise the connections between the benefits ofsharing information, and the often less tangible costs and dangers that can result. However, this needs considerable support from government and the private sector to start the process.
 
For government, we recommend:

  • Each government department using personal information must say how they are accessing personal information, for what purpose, and how it affects people.They should also employ ‘cash-handling’disciplines for dealing with people’s personal information.
  • The government should begin long-term research into the implications of increasing levels of information about individuals, coupled with personalising services. Segmentation and increasing knowledge of individuals will create markets that exclude in ways that current uses ofinformation do not. That will have a significant impact on what is meant by equality. For example, will a new frontier of the welfare state be providing life insurance for certain types ofpeople who are deemed bad investments by private insurance providers?
  • The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) needs greater capacity to cope with the range of demands of an information society, which continue to extend away from just security of data towards data use and the nature of information sharing.
  • ‘Privacy impact assessments’ should be used for major projects across public and private sectors to assess the use of personal information early in development, led by the ICO.
  • There needs to be a serious, renewed debate about the identity card scheme, with the kind of engagement that should have happened at the start of the process. Otherwise, the scheme should be dropped. Meaningful engagement with the public about how the technology should work must be foremost in shaping any national identity scheme.


For business and the private sector, we recommend:

  • The rights of access individuals have to information held about them in the private sector should be extended, including the right to know what groups people have been ‘segmented’into, and allow greater ability for individuals to challenge and change existing information about themselves that they believe to be invalid,incorrect or unfair.
  • There should be a common sense test for privacy statements and personal information policy. The private sector must provide simple,accessible explanations of why personal information is gathered. A move away from jargon is needed. This means, for example,requiring businesses to follow the legal concept ofthe ‘reasonable person’ when drawing up policy statements on personal information.
  • Banks should consider a ‘no claims bonus’ for customers who successfully protect their personal information.




FYI: the new politics of personal information was supported by O2.

Demos_fyi-1
FYI
Authors
Peter Bradwell, Niamh Gallagher
Publication Date
2007-12-07
Publication Type
Report

FYI: the new politics of personal information argues that individuals do not have enough influence over how personal information is used, and that we need to reconnect the everyday experience of giving away our details with the longer-term consequences.

information-sharing.pdf (application/pdf Object)

information-sharing.pdf (application/pdf Object)

MediaBerkman

An excellent feed of interviews, conference recordings and seminars from the Berkman Center for Internet and Society, at HArvard Law School.

Iran shuts down website critical of president | Iran | Guardian Unlimited

Iran shuts down website critical of president | Iran | Guardian Unlimited

Steve Boggan on a Big Brother-style government super-database | Special Reports | Guardian Unlimited

Steve Boggan on a Big Brother-style government super-database | Special Reports | Guardian Unlimited

Benkler on intellectual property

Benkler on intellectual property

Independent Online Edition > Media

Independent Online Edition > Media

Q. What could a boarding pass tell an identity fraudster about you? A. Way too much | Special report

Q. What could a boarding pass tell an identity fraudster about you? A. Way too much | Special report

Comment is free | The web works for the grassroots, but political power still l

Comment is free | The web works for the grassroots, but political power still l

Mashup congress | Netcentric Campaigns

Note on a competition for Sunshine Week and transparency in US government

Opinion Surveys from Privacy Exchange

consumer surveys covering privacy

Privacy Exchange

Good source for privacy reading and general knowledge

Home Office Identity Theft - Who can help?

Home Office Identity Theft website

Resources and practice - Every Child Matters

Info sharing and children's services

Literature in the areas of behavioural economics and psychology, re engaging with creditors

Literature in the areas of behavioural economics and psychology relevant to the understanding of an individual's propensity to engage with their creditors

The end of an era as the Daily Mail loses ground

The end of an era as the Daily Mail loses ground

Kids, the Internet, and the End of Privacy: The Greatest Generation Gap Since Rock and Roll -- New Y

Kids, the Internet, and the End of Privacy: The Greatest Generation Gap Since Rock and Roll -- New Y

Getty snaps up 'citizen photo' site Scoopt from Greenslade

Getty snaps up 'citizen photo' site Scoopt from Greenslade

National survey of British public's views on use of identifiable medical data by the National Cancer

National survey of British public's views on use of identifiable medical data by the National Cancer

FBI subpoenas news from WIRED

FBI subpoenas news from WIRED

SCRIPT-ed: Online Journal

Journal on law and technologies

Garlik - protect your online security, keep track of your online data

Garlik - protect your online security, keep track of your online data

Wireless: Tracking what people do on their cellphones - International Herald Tribune

Wireless: Tracking what people do on their cellphones - International Herald Tribune

Molly

Citizen Information Project: Final Report & Annexes

Citizen Information Project: Final Report & Annexes

BBC NEWS | Hackers hit TK Maxx cardholders

BBC NEWS | Hackers hit TK Maxx cardholders

Free Our Data: the blog

Guardian 'Free Our Data' campaign, urging the release of of public sector data.

Identity Cards Bill

Identity Cards Bill

Can the internet be truly neutral? | Technology | Guardian Unlimited Technology

Can the internet be truly neutral? | Technology | Guardian Unlimited Technology

BNA - World Data Protection Report

BNA - World Data Protection Report

UK Gov deploys lie detectors on benefits claims | The Register

UK Gov deploys lie detectors on benefits claims | The Register

Compete CEO: ISPs Sell Clickstreams For $5 A Month - Seeking Alpha

Compete CEO: ISPs Sell Clickstreams For $5 A Month - Seeking Alpha

Your ISP may be selling your web clicks

Your ISP may be selling your web clicks

UK swamped by data rules - 17 Sep 2003 - Computing.co.uk

UK swamped by data rules - 17 Sep 2003 - Computing.co.uk

Shoppers risk their information online - 10 Apr 2007 - Computing.co.uk

Shoppers risk their information online - 10 Apr 2007 - Computing.co.uk

Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001

Retention of communications data

MySpace UK Visitors Among Most Likely Not to Vote

MySpace UK Visitors Among Most Likely Not to Vote

O'Reilly Radar > Draft Blogger's Code of Conduct

Draft bloggers code of conduct

Comment is free | New technology, new lows for our political discourse

Comment is free | New technology, new lows for our political discourse

Neuromancing the law | The Register

Article on technology and regulation

Data Mining Disclosure Bill Moves Forward

US legislation on reporting data mining activities to congress

Homeland Security data tool

Homeland Security data tool

RIAA and US Govt monitoring P2P sites

RIAA and US Govt monitoring P2P sites

Scoopt code of conduct

Code of conduct for citizen journalism photography site Scoopt.

Tim O'Reilly: Web 2.0 Is About Controlling Data -

Tim O'Reilly on web 2.0 and information control

Surveillance 'intrudes on our lives' | Politics | The Observer

Surveillance 'intrudes on our lives' | Politics | The Observer

Saddam's biometric spy files reused

Saddam's biometric spy files reused

Survey shows 9 in 10 of public is concerned over information protection :: PublicTechnology.net

Survey shows 9 in 10 of public is concerned over information protection :: PublicTechnology.net

Information Age Today Bulldog, ABN Amro customers suffer data theft

Information Age Today Bulldog, ABN Amro customers suffer data theft

ISPA - Data Retention

ISPA - Data Retention

BBC NEWS | Information chief demands reforms

BBC NEWS | Information chief demands reforms

New powers vital to avert surveillance society, says watchdog | Special Reports | Guardian Unlimited

New powers vital to avert surveillance society, says watchdog | Special Reports | Guardian Unlimited

On private affairs and public good / Home UK / FT

More privacy rights de jure and fewer privacy rights de facto

Google may use games to analyse net users | Technology | Guardian Unlimited Technology

Google may use games to analyse net users | Technology | Guardian Unlimited Technology

Straw criticised for "totally unjustified attack" on Information Commissioner

Press release from CFOI on Jack Straw's comments on amendment to FOI bill

Alessandro Acquisti-The Economics of Privacy-Resources on financial privacy,economics,anonymity

Alessandro Acquisti-The Economics of Privacy-Resources on financial privacy,economics,anonymity

Ross Anderson's Home Page

Ross Anderson's Home Page

U.S. Urges EU To Share Airline Data, Homeland Security Chief Says Passenger Information Is Vital To

U.S. Urges EU To Share Airline Data, Homeland Security Chief Says Passenger Information Is Vital To

Debate over legality of Care Record Guarantee

Debate over legality of Care Record Guarantee

PDF conference: danah boyd talk

talk by danah boyd at pdf conference - on young people and online public spaces

Privacy, teens and social networks

report on Pew Internet study on teens privacy behaviour on social network sites

Speech by Rt Hon David Miliband MP at Google conference "We can: politics for the Facebook generatio

Speech by Rt Hon David Miliband MP at Google conference "We can: politics for the Facebook generatio

The Visible Man: An FBI Target Puts His Whole Life Online

The Visible Man: An FBI Target Puts His Whole Life Online

Threat Level - Wired Blogs

Threat Level - Wired Blogs

Your space, MySpace, everybody's space | The Register

It has recently been reported that Attorneys Generals from about a dozen US States, including Connecticut, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Mississippi, Maryland, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Ohio and Pennsylvania have demanded that News Corporation's social networking site MySpace voluntarily deliver a list of all sex offenders who have registered for or used the MySpace social networking service.

J?rgen Habermas: How to save the quality press? - signandsight

J�rgen Habermas: How to save the quality press? - signandsight

Row over school 'drinking' survey

Ofsted survey of 10-15 yr old children designed to 'assess their success in meeting the needs of children and young people'

| Digital ID World | Global warming of the identity ocean

| Digital ID World | Global warming of the identity ocean

The Power of Information Review: online advice sites could improve citizen empowerment

The Power of Information Review: online advice sites could improve citizen empowerment

GOvernment signals embrace of the power of information

GOvernment signals embrace of the power of information

Search me?-News-Tech & Web-The Web-TimesOnline

Search me?-News-Tech & Web-The Web-TimesOnline

Google Is Watching You

More about search engines and privacy...this time from business week

The coming identity wave | CSO Blogs

Digital ID world blog on waves of ideas about identity

2.3m Records Stolen from Fidelity

2.3m Records Stolen from Fidelity

DWP, HMRC and LA info sharing trial

DWP, HMRC and LA info sharing trial

FT.com / Technology - Where do we go from here?

FT.com / Technology - Where do we go from here?

The Office of Fair Trading: Internet shopping

The Office of Fair Trading: Internet shopping

Google Still Using E.U. Data Retention Ruse to Justify Massive Data Collection

Google Still Using E.U. Data Retention Ruse to Justify Massive Data Collection

Caught on camera - and found on Facebook - Times Online

Oxford Uni staff monitoring student photos on facebook

'Big Brother' plan for police to use new road cameras | Special Reports | Guardian Unlimited Politic

'Big Brother' plan for police to use new road cameras | Special Reports | Guardian Unlimited Politic

As Facebook Grows, Longtime Users Draw Privacy Veil

As Facebook Grows, Longtime Users Draw Privacy Veil

BBC NEWS | Magazine | 'ID theft left me in Slovenian prison'

BBC NEWS | Magazine | 'ID theft left me in Slovenian prison'

Identities 'at risk on network websites' - Independent Online Edition > Crime

Identities 'at risk on network websites' - Independent Online Edition > Crime

Blunkett secrecy attack | Special reports | Guardian Unlimited

Blunkett secrecy attack | Special reports | Guardian Unlimited

Cicero | Policy Briefer - Data sharing

Jill Stevens, director of consumer affairs at Experian

Decisions without democracy report

Link to report on secrecy in government, focused on the US.

The Information Sharing Index (England) Regulations 2006

The Information Sharing Index (England) Regulations 2006

Britain will be first country to monitor every car journey - Independent Online Edition > Transport

Britain will be first country to monitor every car journey - Independent Online Edition > Transport

The House of Lords - Science and Technology Reports

Report HL 165 - On Personal Internet Security

Music industry rebuffed across Europe on file-sharing identifications | OUT-LAW.COM

German court refused to order ISPs hand over user details to the music industry

Millions of Facebook users 'leave themselves open to identity theft' - Times Online

Millions of Facebook users 'leave themselves open to identity theft' - Times Online

Google and Microsoft Look to Change Health Care - New York Times

Google and Microsoft Look to Change Health Care - New York Times

Hackers attack world's largest jobs site - Times Online

Hackers attack world's largest jobs site - Times Online

Uncontactable -Times Online

More on the children's database - ContactPoint - from the Times.

Fears raised over access to children's database - Times Online

Coverage of the access rights to ContactPoint - the children's database.

Safety fears over new register of all children - Times Online

Safety fears over new register of all children - Times Online

CCTV drone polices V Festival

CCTV drone polices V Festival

Free Our Data: Not waking the dead: time to make details of the dead avail

Free Our Data: Not waking the dead: time to make details of the dead avail

Identity 2.0 Security |

From Gnucitizen's blog, a video on OpenID of a talk from Dick Hardt.

Information sharing - Every Child Matters

Information sharing - Every Child Matters

ContactPoint - Every Child Matters

ContactPoint - Every Child Matters

Globalization of Personal Data | The Surveillance Project

The Globalisation of Personal Data project is directed by surveillance guru David Lyon, with lots of interesting work.

One in 10 Aussies victims of ID theft: report - web - Technology - smh.com.au

One in 10 Aussies victims of ID theft: report - web - Technology - smh.com.au

Information Assurance Advisory Council > Initiatives > Public Policy

Information Assurance Advisory Council > Initiatives > Public Policy

Schools to fingerprint infants - Telegraph

Schools to fingerprint infants - Telegraph

BBC NEWS | UK | All UK 'must be on DNA database'

BBC NEWS | UK | All UK 'must be on DNA database'

'Promiscuous' RFID a data threat, warns privacy watchdog

'Promiscuous' RFID a data threat, warns privacy watchdog

Liberty - Protecting Civil Liberties Promoting Human Rights : Britain's privacy

Liberty - Protecting Civil Liberties Promoting Human Rights : Britain's privacy

Concern over NHS's IT systems after 50 view celebrity's details | Health | SocietyGuardian.co.uk

Concern over NHS's IT systems after 50 view celebrity's details | Health | SocietyGuardian.co.uk

Turner Prize 2006 - Phil Collins

Turner Prize 2006 - Phil Collins

RIAA Jury Finds Minnesota Woman Liable for Piracy, Awards $222,000 on Threat Level

RIAA Jury Finds Minnesota Woman Liable for Piracy, Awards $222,000 on Threat Level

Peter

Serious Organised Crime Agency - marketing fraud figures

Serious Organised Crime Agency - marketing fraud figures

Publications Alfred Kobsa

Alfred Kobsa, who has done a lot of research into the privacy implications of personalisation.

Roger Clarke's 'eHealth Records'

Piece on 'privacy versus quality of care', looking critically at the privacy issues of sharing patient health records.

BBC NEWS | World | Europe | EU lays out anti-terror proposals

BBC NEWS | World | Europe | EU lays out anti-terror proposals

Web 2.0: new internet, new etiquette . . . new law? - Times Online

Web 2.0: new internet, new etiquette . . . new law? - Times Online

BBC NEWS | Technology | Social networkers warned of risk

Report on a Get Safe Online survey of the uses of social networks and the information risks associated with it.

Family doctors to shun national database of patients' records | Society | The Guardian

Family doctors to shun national database of patients' records | Society | The Guardian

Biometrics are not a panacea for data loss

Letter from some big hitting privacy and tech experts criticising rhetoric of biometrics.

It really is not about ownership of identity data | CSO Blogs

Great post from Eric Norlin of Digital ID World on control of personal data

Potlatch: the public sphere as confessional

Potlatch: the public sphere as confessional

Archrights videos on ContactPoint database

Archrights videos on ContactPoint database

It's time to overhaul copyright law | Technology | guardian.co.uk

Cory Doctorow on why copyright law needs to spot the differences between the different uses of copyrighted work.

U.K. student records to sit in accessible database | CNET News.com

U.K. student records to sit in accessible database | CNET News.com

MIAP Managing Information Across Partners - About the MIAP programme

MIAP Managing Information Across Partners - About the MIAP programme

Kim Cameron's THE LAWS OF IDENTITY

Kim Cameron's THE LAWS OF IDENTITY

Our surveillance society goes online | Technology | The Guardian

Excellent article on a new book looking at the implications of automated data reading and analysis.

Open Rights Group Newsblog : Blog Archive ? Managers prepared to exploit customers? private data

Open Rights Group Newsblog : Blog Archive � Managers prepared to exploit customers? private data

Finland privacy judgment

Finland privacy judgment

Google's Gatekeepers - NYTimes.com

Jeff Rosen on Google

Peter

AC Grayling on Privacy

AC Grayling on Privacy

Mar 25

“Is THIS the digital election??!?!”

Thishani Nadesan says that a digital election is about more than web savvy MPs.

Feb 3

Good consumers

Peter Bradwell on why the iPad is not a mark of social progress.

Nov 18

The value of numbers

Peter Bradwell thinks people should profit from the use of their personal information.

Aug 22

Identity and information

'The Internet was built without a way to know who and what you are connecting to.'...

Jun 24

TechnoPresident?

In 2006, David Cameron famously described Gordon Brown as an 'analogue politician in...

Feb 12

Musical 'mares

It's not Friday - but can I rant? Unsurprising reports today of some imminent proposals...

Dec 13

QDOS

The FYI pamphlet was big on the need for ideas that can help people manage their personal...

Dec 12

FYI

Last Friday, 7th December, we launched FYI: the new politics of personal information, a...

Nov 22

The new politics of personal information

We've been telling anyone that will listen for a long time that personal information...

Nov 15

Crossing the 'e's

"The aim of border control is to sort traffic into legitimate and non-legitimate and...

Nov 5

The type of information people have matters

Big 'Big Brother' headline today, on the front of the Daily Mail. A written answer...

Oct 11

The structured web

I just read a really useful post from the Read/WriteWeb blog about where the internet is...

Oct 6

The hair and the home office

Being pretty geeky, it pleases me when stories that you might assume are a bit tecchie make...

Sep 30

Hearing difficulties

The front page of the Mail on Sunday was rather enjoyable today, expressing as it did tangible...

Sep 5

Did Columbo need DNA?

There's some coverage on the BBC website of the 'DNA database' - the store...

Aug 14

I know what you did last summer - and I can save you 25%

It’s striking how frequently there are stories about the insecurity of our personal...

Jul 19

Potter Privacy 'Police' Point to Photo 'Prints'

Just read on Times online how Canon engineers, joining the hunt for the culprit in the leaked...

Jul 17

You are not anonymous

Reading a story about a further round of lawsuits from the International Federation of the...

Jul 17

Privacy on social networks

Just read a story about Oxford University using Facebook to find evidence from their students...

Jun 29

Search me...

We're holding an event with Google next Thursday evening at their offices in Victoria...

Jun 11

Rate my privacy

A really useful report from Privacy International - rankings of the major internet companies...

May 25

google me this, google me that...

...how many search results for my personality came back?We ran a roundtable discussion yesterday...

May 21

Mashup politics - when everyday democracy meets the web

The personal democracy forum conference (and unconference) are over until 2008. Two main...

May 19

Everyday democracy takes on NY

The second day of the pdf conference has taken on the form of an 'unconference'...

May 18

NYC and 'personal democracy'

Peter Bradwell, Niamh Gallagher and I are representing Demos at the Personal Democracy Forum...

Apr 23

'Web 2.0' and data control

I just found an interesting quote in a Wired interview with Tim O'Reilly.  It ties...

Apr 10

Customers also bought:

I spotted some news today (press release here) about Sainsbury's renewing its contract...

Apr 4

Stop chewing!

I can't help but think of those particularly miserly teachers whose hatred of a pupil...

Mar 5

FYI: We need to know. Period

The Times leads with an excellent piece on the freedom of information. According to the...